Bottom line: Etsy imho is no longer a viable place to shop. In earlier days i enjoyed purchasing unique, home-made or custom made items.

Now the site seems to me to be loaded with over-priced mass-produced stuff. Adding insult to injury, Etsy does not protect its buyers - unlike Ebay which is terrific in that regard. So why on earth shop Etsy, except for maybe inexpensive items, if you have money to burn. On Dec 2, 2017, i ordered custom-made felt slippers from an overseas shop.

The seller advertised their goods as 'Handmade, Made to order'. That's why i shopped there; i am a hard-to-find 9 1/2 AA - which i made perfectly clear: "My foot size, US measurement: 9 1/2 AA; I have a fairly high instep; definitely NOT flat." Why she asked about instep is beyond me. Slippers are flat. The slippers that arrived - January 8, 2018 - would be too big for an elephant!

I suspect not handmade, and definitely not custom-made. Nor do they look like the image posted. I was SO SO deflated when they arrived, and then angry. I wrote to the seller; no response.

So i left a negative review. That got attention; however, the seller wanted me to ship the package back - my expense - and either get my money back ($52; a lot to me), or let her try again. I decided to cut my losses. But not before filing a complaint at Etsy, and uploading photos.

But Etsy does not get involved. My guess is that this site will fade...as it should.

FYI: i posted this also on ConsumerAffairs; what an eyeful there from other Etsy buyers AND sellers! Not a good company; especially after Josh Silverman became CEO in November, 2017.

Reason of review: Not as described/ advertised.

Monetary Loss: $62.

Preferred solution: Full refund.

Etsy Pros: Products until now.

Etsy Cons: Deceptive store, No receiving the product i paid for.

Do You Have Something To Say ?
Write a review


You will be automatically registered on our site. Username and password will be sent to you via email.
Post Comment

Etsy Reviews

  1. 565 reviews
  2. 140 reviews
  3. 97 reviews
  4. 57 reviews
  5. 62 reviews
Etsy reviews