Not resolved

I ordered a ring from the Kristinelily shop on Etsy. After paying massive import taxes (would have been nice to know beforehand), turns out the shop sent a much smaller size, I sent a photo with a ring I already owned to show it.

I was strung along and told to wait. When I eventually reported to Etsy, what do you know, my "case eligibility" had magically expired, along with my right to review on Etsy. Yes, along with my right to post a review.

I've payed $ 105, and have nothing to show for it, even though Kristine Lily admitted she sent the wrong size, not even any excuse. Tip for consumers: Don't do it because they do not care when things go wrong and will not reimburse you.

Reason of review: Wrong size ring. .

Monetary Loss: $105.

Preferred solution: Full refund.

Etsy Cons: Terrible customer service, Indifferent about mistakes, Lost a lot of money.

Do You Have Something To Say ?
Write a review

Comments is temporarily operating in read-only mode and users cannot make any changes to the information, publish comments or reviews. Please come back in a couple of minutes.

Well- import fees are the customer's responsibility. It's so unnerving to constantly be asked to change the value or mark as a gift from customers.

This is very illegal and if caught, a seller could lose their entire business. Jail time even. It's practically impossible for a seller from the US to know import and duty taxes and fees for all the countries they ship to and for a customer to complain about it is just silly. If you are going to order from overseas it's your responsibility to know what your country charges/requires.

Second- if the seller took so long to ship that your protection ran out then you should report them to etsy.

Generally they can re-open a case like that and hold the seller responsible.

You just have to contact them directly. I believe is a good email address for that...

@Former etsy seller

Thanks for taking time to write your reaction. I understand you wouldn't want to do anything illegal.

However I only said it would have been good to have been reminded beforehand that I was going to pay import taxes. Even if it's true I ought to have known it, I didn't. I might still have gone ahead and ordered but I just would have liked to have had a reminder on the website. Now I know.

Of course if I had known it was the wrong ring, I wouldn't have decided at the post office to go ahead and pay the taxes in order to get it. When I had sent it back the next day and I got nowhere with KristineLily, I did report to Etsy it was the wrong ring. As a matter of fact I wrote them 28 e-mails, and they wrote back over the course of the next months. Like I said, the 'case eligibility' had run out in the end.

All I got was that they were glad of my understanding that they could do nothing. I guess an apology fell under the 'nothing' category too. Well, I certainly understand that I should never go through Etsy again. Not from Etsy or KristineLily, did I get anything.

It was my own trustworthy mastercard company who refunded half the amount I lost; the price of the ring. Well half feels a lot better than nothing, and the other half was an expensive lesson.

Etsy Reviews

  1. 213 reviews
  2. 54 reviews
  3. 34 reviews
  4. 18 reviews
  5. 22 reviews
Etsy reviews